Child Adultification in Brazil: A Growing Concern and Legislative Response
In Brazil, a significant and urgent public debate has recently erupted around the complex and sensitive concept of “child adultification” (adultização infantil), drawing widespread attention from various sectors of society, including social media users, child development experts, educators, and crucially, the National Congress. At its core, child adultification refers to the premature exposure of children to behaviors, responsibilities, and expectations typically reserved for adults, often with detrimental effects on their development. The controversy gained significant momentum following a prominent Brazilian YouTuber’s powerful denunciation of certain digital influencers allegedly exploiting minors for the creation of online content, pushing this critical issue into the national spotlight and accelerating the demand for robust legislative intervention.
Understanding Child Adultification: Recognizing the Signs and Grappling with the Impacts
Child adultification is not a monolithic concept; it manifests in various concerning and often insidious ways, reflecting the complex interplay between societal pressures, digital trends, and parental oversight. According to leading organizations dedicated to child protection, such as Fundação Abrinq and Instituto Alana, the signs of adultification can be observed in several key areas. These include, but are not limited to, the early and inappropriate use of sexualized clothing and makeup, the reproduction of eroticized gestures and choreographies, unrestricted and unsupervised access to sexualized music, videos, and digital influencers, and perhaps most subtly, undue pressure on children to “act older” in order to gain social acceptance, achieve online popularity, or even contribute financially to their households.
The impacts of this premature exposure are far-reaching and can leave deep, lasting scars on a child’s developing psyche. Children subjected to adultification are at a significantly higher risk of developing a range of emotional and psychological problems, such as anxiety and depression. They may also face difficulties in socialization and in forming a healthy self-identity. Experts warn that this phenomenon directly compromises the healthy construction of self-esteem and self-perception, making these children disproportionately vulnerable to various forms of exploitation, particularly within the vast and often unregulated digital realm where content can be easily manipulated and widely disseminated.
The Spark That Ignited the Debate: Public Outcry and Legislative Momentum
The recent surge in public awareness and the subsequent political mobilization were largely ignited by a compelling video from Brazilian YouTuber Felca, who critically addressed the adultification of children, highlighting cases of “child coaches” and young adolescents discussing investments online. His video, which blended irony with profound seriousness, specifically accused a well-known influencer, Hytalo Santos, of exploiting minors for content creation. This powerful denunciation resonated deeply with the public, leading to a rapid escalation of the debate and prompting a swift response from lawmakers.
The gravity of the situation was further underscored by the fact that the influencer, Hytalo Santos, was already under investigation by the Public Prosecutor’s Office in Paraíba since 2024 for alleged exploitation of minors in online content. This pre-existing legal scrutiny, combined with the public outcry and the compelling testimonies from child development experts, collectively emphasized the critical and immediate need for robust legal frameworks. These frameworks are essential to protect children from the pervasive and evolving risks inherent in the digital environment, where the lines between entertainment, influence, and exploitation can become dangerously blurred.
Brazil’s Comprehensive Legislative Response: A Landmark Bill for Digital Protection
In direct response to this escalating national concern, the Brazilian Congress has taken decisive and comprehensive action. The Chamber of Deputies initially established a dedicated working group tasked with drafting specific legislation to address the issue. Building on these efforts, and in a significant legislative milestone, the Senate most recently approved a landmark bill, PL 2.628/2022. This proposed law is specifically designed to enhance the protection of children and adolescents within digital environments. Currently awaiting presidential sanction, this bill is widely regarded as a pioneering effort in the Americas, setting a potential precedent for how nations can address the complex challenges posed by child adultification and digital exploitation.
The bill encompasses a wide array of crucial measures, reflecting a holistic approach to safeguarding minors online:
-
Mandatory Content Removal and Reporting: The legislation mandates the immediate removal of any content related to child abuse, sexual exploitation, kidnapping, or grooming. Furthermore, platforms are legally obligated to notify competent national and international authorities without delay. Beyond these severe cases, platforms are also required to remove any content deemed offensive to children upon notification from victims, their legal representatives, the Public Prosecutor’s Office, or child advocacy organizations, even in the absence of a judicial order. This proactive removal mechanism aims to swiftly mitigate harm.
-
Enhanced Parental Supervision and Strict Age Verification: A cornerstone of the bill is the requirement for social media accounts of children up to 16 years old to be formally linked to a responsible adult. Crucially, the bill explicitly prohibits age verification based solely on a user’s self-declaration, demanding more robust and verifiable methods. Companies are also mandated to provide accessible and user-friendly parental supervision tools. These tools are designed to offer the maximum level of protection by default, including functionalities such as blocking unauthorized communication between children and unapproved adults, limiting features that might encourage excessive use (like auto-play videos and incessant notifications), controlling recommendation algorithms to prevent exposure to inappropriate content, and restricting the sharing of geolocation data. Parents and guardians will also gain access to controls allowing them to configure and manage their child’s account settings, define privacy rules, restrict in-app purchases and financial transactions, and identify adult profiles with whom their children interact.
-
Severe Penalties for Non-Compliance: The bill introduces a tiered system of penalties for non-compliance, ranging from warnings and fines to more severe measures. Fines can be substantial, reaching up to 10% of the economic group’s revenue in Brazil from the previous fiscal year, or up to R$ 50 million (approximately USD 10 million) per infraction if revenue data is unavailable. Foreign companies are explicitly held jointly responsible for fines applied to their Brazilian subsidiaries or branches, ensuring accountability across international operations. In the most egregious cases, non-compliant entities may face suspension or even outright prohibition of their activities, though these most severe penalties require judicial imposition.
-
Regulation of Loot Boxes and Targeted Advertising: Addressing concerns about addictive behaviors and potential links to gambling, the bill reinstates a ban on “loot boxes” in electronic games specifically for children and adolescents. It also strictly prohibits profiling children for targeted advertising purposes and explicitly bans the use of advanced technologies such as emotional analysis, augmented reality, extended reality, and virtual reality for advertising directed at this vulnerable age group.
-
Robust Data Protection and Safeguarding Freedom of Expression: The legislation places a strong emphasis on the protection of children’s personal data, prohibiting any processing that could lead to violations of their privacy or other protected rights. Importantly, the bill also seeks to strike a delicate balance by stipulating that regulations cannot impose mechanisms of massive, generic, or indiscriminate surveillance. It explicitly forbids practices that compromise fundamental rights to freedom of expression, privacy, and the integral protection and differentiated treatment of children’s and adolescents’ personal data.
This comprehensive legislative response by Brazil reflects a growing global awareness of the multifaceted challenges children face in an increasingly digitalized world. Brazil’s proactive and detailed stance aims not only to empower parents and hold technology providers accountable but also to fundamentally reshape the digital environment to foster healthy development rather than premature adultification and exploitation. The ongoing debate, however, continues to highlight the inherent complexities in balancing robust protection measures with the fundamental principles of freedom of expression, particularly concerning the regulation and moderation practices of large social media platforms. This bill represents a significant step forward in defining the responsibilities of digital platforms towards their youngest users.
References:
